Featured Article

In 1790, Alexander Hamilton, the Secretary of Treasury for President George Washington, proposed a financial plan that included implementing taxes on whiskey and several other items while establishing a national government-run bank. While the plan was intended to help the United States’ economy, it was met with stiff opposition from many politicians, including James Madison and Thomas Jefferson. While Madison and Jefferson’s opposition was widely seen as detrimental to the country and hostile to Hamilton’s plan, there were actually many positive benefits to the opposition’s stance.

When Madison and Jefferson opposed Hamilton’s plan, it allowed for the emergence of a newly developed system that separated executive and legislative powers, with both branches competing to fund and push forward their desired policies. During this time period, the executive branch of the government had much more political power than it does today. Because of Madison and Jefferson’s opposition, the legislative branch was allowed to grow and expand, forcing the executive branch to take a back seat and allowing for the emergence of a more separate system.

Furthermore, the opposition to Hamilton’s plan sparked a great deal of public deliberation and discussion. The debate between Hamiltonians and their opponents went on for months, giving members of the public a much clearer understanding of the implications of Hamilton’s plan and allowing them to have more control over their individual governmental decisions. This debate was instrumental in teaching the public about how the government was run and encouraged the formation of a more distributed and decentralized system of government.

Madison and Jefferson’s opposition also spurred the development of the Democratic-Republican Party, which Jefferson co-led with Madison. This party was the precursor to today’s modern Democratic Party and played an important role in the development of the United States’ political landscape. The Democratic-Republican Party was created around the ideals of individual liberty, state sovereignty, and limited government, all ideas which have since been incorporated into the United States’ Constitution.

Without James Madison and Thomas Jefferson’s opposition to Alexander Hamilton’s plans, the development of the United States’ government as we know it today would have been drastically different. While they were often met with a great deal of criticism and hostility for their views, the positive effects of the opposition can not be denied. Madison and Jefferson’s arguments ultimately encouraged a separation of powers between the executive and legislative governments, sparked public debate which allowed for more informed individuals, and led the creation of the Democratic-Republican Party, all of which have had a huge influence on the United States’ government today.